First-Time Founder Guide

Your First Startup Exit

A complete walkthrough for first-time founders. Avoid costly mistakes, build the right team, and navigate the exit process with confidence.

Why This Guide Exists

First-time founders typically leave 20-40% of deal value on the table due to inexperience. You only get one shot at your first exit — this guide helps you get it right.

The Complete Journey

Emotional Preparation

Understand the psychological journey of selling your company and prepare for the emotional rollercoaster

Build Your Exit Team

Assemble the right advisors: M&A lawyer, tax accountant, business broker or investment banker

Prepare Your Business

Get finances audit-ready, clean up legal docs, document processes, and maximize value

Navigate Due Diligence

Know what buyers will investigate and how to respond without killing the deal

Negotiate Like a Pro

Understand term sheets, valuation adjustments, earn-outs, and how to get the best deal

Close Successfully

Final steps to closing, escrow, transition planning, and what happens after you sign

Common First-Timer Mistakes

Starting exit prep too late

Consequence: Deal delays, lower valuation, or deals falling apart during DD

Solution: Start preparing 12-18 months before you plan to sell

Not hiring experienced advisors

Consequence: Leave $500K+ on the table, accept bad terms, miss red flags

Solution: Hire M&A lawyer and accountant who've done 10+ deals in your size range

Being emotionally attached to valuation

Consequence: Walking away from good deals, negotiating poorly, alienating buyers

Solution: Get 3rd party valuation early, understand market comps, focus on total deal value

Sharing too much too early

Consequence: Lose leverage, competitors learn your strategy, employees get spooked

Solution: Use NDAs, share info progressively, keep deal confidential until LOI

Ignoring cultural fit with buyer

Consequence: Miserable transition period, customers/employees leave, earnout at risk

Solution: Interview the buyer as much as they interview you. Culture matters.

Not understanding tax implications

Consequence: Huge unexpected tax bills, poor asset vs stock sale structure

Solution: Consult tax advisor before accepting LOI. Structure matters enormously.

Step-by-Step Exit Process

Here's what to expect from preparation through closing. Timeline assumes a $5-50M SaaS exit.

Preparation Phase

6-12 months before
  • Get financial audit or reviewed statements
  • Clean up cap table and resolve any disputes
  • Document all processes and reduce founder dependency
  • Improve key metrics (ARR growth, churn, margins)
  • Build your exit team (lawyer, accountant, advisor)

Going to Market

Month 1-2
  • Create compelling CIM (Confidential Information Memorandum)
  • Identify and qualify potential buyers
  • Send teasers to gauge interest
  • Sign NDAs with interested parties
  • Hold management presentations

Initial Due Diligence

Month 2-3
  • Provide data room access to serious buyers
  • Answer buyer questions and requests
  • Negotiate LOI (Letter of Intent) terms
  • Choose preferred buyer and sign LOI
  • Set up deal timeline and milestones

Deep Due Diligence

Month 3-5
  • Buyer conducts extensive financial, legal, technical DD
  • Customer reference calls
  • Technology audit and security review
  • Employee and contractor documentation review
  • Working capital and financial model validation

Final Negotiation

Month 5-6
  • Review and negotiate purchase agreement
  • Finalize employment/transition agreements
  • Resolve any issues discovered in DD
  • Negotiate final price adjustments
  • Agree on escrow and earnout terms

Closing & Transition

Month 6+
  • Sign final documents and transfer ownership
  • Receive payment (minus escrow holdback)
  • Begin transition period (typically 30-90 days)
  • Train new owners, introduce to customers
  • Fulfill earnout obligations if applicable

Build Your Exit Team

Don't go it alone. These professionals will more than pay for themselves.

M&A Attorney

$15K-50K+

When to hire: Before you talk to any buyers

Why you need them: Reviews LOI, negotiates purchase agreement, protects you from liability

Tax Accountant/CPA

$5K-20K

When to hire: Before accepting LOI

Why you need them: Tax planning can save you hundreds of thousands. Stock vs asset sale matters.

Business Broker or Investment Banker

10-15% of sale price

When to hire: Optional, depends on size

Why you need them: Helps find buyers, manage process, negotiate. Worth it for deals $5M+

Financial Advisor

1% of assets annually

When to hire: After closing

Why you need them: Help you invest proceeds wisely and avoid lifestyle inflation

The Emotional Journey

Selling your company is intensely emotional. Here's what to expect and how to cope:

Decision to Sell

You'll feel: Excitement mixed with uncertainty

Advice: It's okay to have mixed feelings. Talk to founders who've exited before.

During Due Diligence

You'll feel: Scrutinized, defensive, exhausted

Advice: Remember: tough questions don't mean they're backing out. It's normal process.

Deal at Risk

You'll feel: Panic, desperation, anger

Advice: Most deals hit bumps. Stay calm. Have your advisor handle emotional negotiations.

Just After Closing

You'll feel: Relief, joy, but also emptiness

Advice: Totally normal to feel lost. Take time off before deciding what's next.

Key Takeaways

  • Start early: Begin preparing 12-18 months before you want to sell
  • Hire experts: M&A lawyer and tax accountant are non-negotiable
  • Expect 6-12 months: From first buyer conversation to closing
  • Manage emotions: Stay objective. Let advisors handle tough negotiations
  • Cultural fit matters: Don't just optimize for price. Bad buyer = miserable transition

Get Your Personalized Exit Roadmap

Get a customized exit strategy and timeline based on your specific business metrics.

EvalyMe Logo
EvalyMe
AI-Powered

Plan your app's exit like a pro with our AI-powered valuation tool and exit strategy coach.

500+ founders
$50M+ valued

Product

  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Case Studies

Resources

  • Valuation Guide
  • Exit Playbook
  • Case Studies

Company

  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms

© 2025 Evaly.Me

Secure & Trusted
β 1.12.09
All systems operational

📣Subscribe to The Exit Signal

Get founder-first insights, cheeky growth tips, and SaaS exit signals straight to your inbox. No spam, just signal. 🚦

"Smart founders plan their exit before they need it. Get the insights that separate successful exits from fire sales."